Amore Pizza - Nutley: Fresh, Authentic Pizza in Nutley, NJ

I’ve been eating here since it first opened, and it’s easily one of our favorites—in fact, it’s the only place we order from weekly. I recently came across a review mentioning “freezer burned” and “rotting” pizza, and I find that extremely hard to believe. Jack and his team consistently put out high-quality, fresh food and take pride in what they serve. The quality, freshness, and consistency are what make this place one of the best in the Nutley/Belleville area. Their dough and sauces are excellent, and no matter which pie you choose, it’s always awesome. Please do not let that review keep you from trying their food.

The Giuseppe is phenomenal. The crust is crispy yet airy with a little garlic kick to it. I also loved the grandma slice. Worth the 50 min drive. Can’t wait to go back

I’m sorry but this pizza is incredible. Some of the best classic pan pizza and thin crust stuff you can find. Just had it yesterday and am still thinking of it. Jack, the owner, is a good dude — go get some!

Great tasting pizza, rich sauce, great cheese this is like a real quick bite to eat. Two slices and a soda came up to eight dollars again great pizza don’t do what I do and put your head in the window. They serve pizza out of a shake shack like a window , great pizza great service I’ll be back 5 stars

Decided to come in for a cheese pizza and was kindly greeted by Carlos. He was very nice and prepared my order right away. The inside of the store was small and cozy and there were covered tables outside along with an ordering window. The pizza tasted delicious. I had a great experience and can't wait to try other flavors!

I went to Amore Pizza for the first time today, and let me tell you the pizza won’t disappoint! The sauce was full of amazing flavor, and whatever dough they’re using, they need to keep it going it’s delicious. The cashier, Daniel, was really nice and welcoming. The outdoor area is spacious, there’s a big parking lot, and the prices are just as impressive as the food. I’ll definitely be coming back more often!

Went here for the first time last night on a date night with the wife. Yes I am a lucky man when we both enjoy a great pie outside for a date! Firstly, the food is prepared surprisingly fast. The pictures of the pizzas above the ordering window are mostly described as crispy or thin or both- so many to choose from. My kinda place. The Italia had the perfect ratio of cheese and flavorful sauce with the kinda crisp/char I love on the edges. Hey if you like pizzas where you dont eat the crust, I don’t wanna hear it lol. Heres my tip: Get the fries as well! I love fries as much as I love pizza and these were so crisp on the outside with the perfect amount of salt that I could have eaten them without the ketchup! Cant wait to get back and deal with the nice problem of which style to try next!